[Admin complaint: dsdiy]

Admin(s) Key: @Dsdiy

Your ckey (Byond username): @Guccimaneitellem

Your Discord name (if applicable): katze#7705

Date(s) of incident (GMT preferred): 2022-08-12, 15:14:02

ROUND ID: N/A

Nature of complaint: Misapplication of rules (Rule 5)

Brief description: tl;dr command banned for not being professional enough AFTER demotion from HOP to assistant.

Full description of events: It is 100% immoral to hold a player to another role's requirements for IC/RP behavior. If the player has been demoted or switched from a role, they have completely severed all ties with the former role and should be treated as such. Command Rule 5'ing someone after demotion on the basis of RP is in itself breaking RP, as getting knocked down to 0 and acting unhinged is something that should not surprise anyone at any level, IRL or not.

IF rule 5 is to be extended like this post role, then it should state so in the advanced rules section. But that sets up a really bad precedent: it means that anyone can be punished for failing to meet their previous roles' requirements after demotion or switching. Logically meaning, sec who were demoted can get job banned for not following space law, doctors can get job banned for valid hunting after going to sec, assistants can be command banned for not being professional after resigning or demotion, and hell, former cultists can be antag banned for fighting them at the final summon after being deconverted.

The real reason this happened was because I have bad notes from command roles before I was hard banned, and I have been trying to improve, which is why getting job banned by an unmentioned extension to a rule that I would not have "broken" if I knew it existed in the first place is pretty annoying.

Thanks and have a good one.