Honestly, I've had good RP with people that have been shut down by admins because.. they don't agree with the type of RP? or we aren't interacting with eachother in a way the admins would like us to even if it isn't directly impacting anyone in round. Paradise definitely has its LRP moments, but I'd rather have those than the "RP" I see most of the time, which is usually between a few people that have some nuts interpersonal lore only they are clued in on. It results in some clique being formed around that "RP" that ends up excluding everyone else. From everything I have experienced and been told, that is the type of roleplay the admin team wants to see. I personally think people should be allowed to do more gimmicky characters, and when people do, I see most people in round having fun with it. its a silly space game, I think that should be embraced rather than squandered, especially on an MRP server. I truly think people take paradise far too seriously for what it is.
Another thing is that the people that do these gimmick characters, can only do it with certain admins on. That's simply not how it should be. People shouldn't have to form their playstyles around which admin(s) are on because of the ridiculously inconsistent enforcement and rulings. It's a coin toss if you can do something or not based on if an admin is in a good mood that day or even if they have some personal grudge against you as a player or person. Two surveys went out a few months ago and I have yet to see.. well, anything about them since. There is nearly zero transparency as to what is going on behind the scenes, or if anything is at all. I'm not trying to put down or discourage the admin team, it is voluntary work after all. However, I feel this is the sentiment shared by most regular players and if things keep going the way they have been, they will all be driven away for one reason or another.